Programming Forums > Application Development > Java

shangnyun · Jun 7th, 2005, 1:50 PM

Help me out here, boys. I'm a newb-programmer and am really liking Java so far. I'm stuck on this problem though. Here's the code:

(Toggle Plain Text)

import java.util.*;

public class FirstProgram
{
    public static void main(String[] args)
    {
        System.out.println("Hello out there.");
        System.out.println("Want to talk some more?");
        System.out.println("Answer y for yes or n for no.");

        Scanner scannerObject = new Scanner(System.in);
        String answerLetter;
        answerLetter = scannerObject.next();
        
        if (answerLetter == "y")
            System.out.println("Nice weather we are having.");
        if (answerLetter == "n")
        	System.out.println("Good-bye.");

        System.out.println("Press Enter key to end program.");
        String junk;
        junk = scannerObject.next();
    }
}

This is a problem from my book. I took the provided source-code and was supposed to change it around so that the program returns something when the user inputs the char "n". Now, this source-code comes from a book that was originally based on Java 1.4.2, so the author, Walter Savitch, provided a keyboard input class called SavitchIn.java. I have his class and could use it, but I figured I might as well try getting used to the newly introduced Scanner class in Java 5.0. Well, I'm not so sure if that was a good idea anymore. The Scanner class is driving me NUTS.
The problem here is that I need to input a CHAR from the keyboard. I searched myself dumb to find if there is a char-specific input method for the Scanner class, and found nothing. There are

nextInt();
nextDouble();
nextLong();
...
etc.

a bunch of them like that... but no nextChar(); exists! So I figured I could try using the method for String input instead, which is just next();
So far, so good. I used this at first:

(Toggle Plain Text)

 
if (answerLetter = "y")
    System.out.println("Nice weather we are having.");
if (answerLetter = "n")
    System.out.println("Good-bye.");

and I got no compile errors with this, but run-time errors. The compiler told me that boolean values are required here. I have no clue why... so I substituted the "="s with =='s and voila, no compile errors, no run-time errors. Great. BUT now the program has a logical error, which again I don't quite understand. It doesn't matter whether you input "y" or "n", it will always just print "Press Enter key to end program" instead of printing any of the strings in the IF statements

The code is obvious/simple enoug... help a brother out!

Knight · Jun 7th, 2005, 1:56 PM

Wait wait wait (brain flooded).. I've grown up on Java 1.2 and 1.4. What is the scanner class supposed to accomplish in Java 5? If I knew that, I would be of more help

Gilward Kukel · Jun 7th, 2005, 3:00 PM

try this:

(Toggle Plain Text)

        if ("y".equals(answerLetter))
            System.out.println("Nice weather we are having.");
        if ("n".equals(answerLetter))
        	System.out.println("Good-bye.");

Knight · Jun 7th, 2005, 3:22 PM

*smacks himself in the head*
How could I forget that! I always seem to miss the little things :p . Gilward Kukel is correct. When comparing Strings, make sure to use the equals() method or the equalsIgnoreCase() method. If you're using the == to compare (2) strings, if I remember correctly, it will compare their memory addresses, which will not be the same thus returning false.

Mjordan2nd · Jun 7th, 2005, 3:34 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Knight

Wait wait wait (brain flooded).. I've grown up on Java 1.2 and 1.4. What is the scanner class supposed to accomplish in Java 5? If I knew that, I would be of more help

Scanner is just another way to get input; in my opinion, much more efficient than BufferedReader.

shangnyun · Jun 7th, 2005, 8:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Gilward Kukel

try this:

(Toggle Plain Text)

        if ("y".equals(answerLetter))
            System.out.println("Nice weather we are having.");
        if ("n".equals(answerLetter))
        	System.out.println("Good-bye.");

That worked!! Thanks.. the stupid thing is I even knew I had to use the "equals" method... but never got around to it. Thanks a lot for making that crystal-clear to me

One more thing... here is the ORIGINAL, unchanged source-code, that I am supposed to edit in such a way that the program responds with a message when the user enteres 'n' at the prompt. Those are the precise words of the assignment:

(Toggle Plain Text)

public class FirstProgram
{
    public static void main(String[] args)
    {
        System.out.println("Hello out there.");
        System.out.println("Want to talk some more?");
        System.out.println("Answer y for yes or n for no.");

        char answerLetter;
        answerLetter = SavitchIn.readLineNonwhiteChar();
        if (answerLetter == 'y')
            System.out.println("Nice weather we are having.");

        System.out.println("Good-bye.");

        System.out.println("Press Enter key to end program.");
        String junk;
        junk = SavitchIn.readLine();
    }
}

What do you think now... did I do a good job on this or did I miss anything/do too much? Also, keep in mind that this is a programming project from the very FIRST chapter from an introductory Java programming book. Hence, this problem is supposed to be really, really simple. No advanced classes/methods, absolutely nothing fancy... I just have to edit the above code in such a way that the program responds with a message when the user enters 'n' at the prompt.
What's bugging me royally is that I can't seem to find a Scanner method that will allow specifically for CHAR input. It sucks that I have to resort to String input, because it is not as exact. CHAR is exactly what I need

Thanks for all your quick help, guys!

PS
Here's a info-link about the SavitchIn class just in case you're wondering: http://www.fas.harvard.edu/~libe50a/...SavitchIn.html

The reason that class exists is because Java 1.5.0 or 5.0 (whatever it is they call it now), Java had no library dedicated to keyboard input. Now it does, in 5.0, with the Scanner class. That's why all this is a bit confusing. I have the 4th edition book, class uses the 3rd edition. 3rd = Java 1.4.2 -- my book, 4th = Java 1.5.0/5.0.

Dameon · Jun 7th, 2005, 8:41 PM

How about using a DataInputStream? It has a readChar method. To create one is just like with Scanner:

(Toggle Plain Text)

DataInputStream dataObject = new DataInputStream(System.in);

shangnyun · Jun 7th, 2005, 8:46 PM

I would... but I know absolutely nothing about that

. My book does not at all mention that in the first chapter, and I'd like to stick to the book. However, given that I don't have the book the problem is from, that statement sorta goes out the window right there...

This is the very FIRST problem in the book, from chapter 1! WTF... why can't I get this right? OMG, what will do with chapter 4 problems? Daaaayum

shangnyun · Jun 7th, 2005, 8:48 PM

Now that I think about it... could someone please just tell me how to use the SavitchIn class? It'll be outdated that way, but I will be done and the professor uses the old book anyway, so he's EXPECTING SavitchIn to be used. He doesn't care how we do it, so it'd be cool if I could use the Scanner class, but we're obviously having problems here

. So... how do I use a random class that's not part of the standard Java package? See that link I posted earlier on info on the class. I have a SavitchIn.java file. Wha do I do with that in order to be able to use it as a class for keyboard input in my program? Thank you.

Berto · Jun 8th, 2005, 3:51 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Knight

*smacks himself in the head*
How could I forget that! I always seem to miss the little things :p . Gilward Kukel is correct. When comparing Strings, make sure to use the equals() method or the equalsIgnoreCase() method. If you're using the == to compare (2) strings, if I remember correctly, it will compare their memory addresses, which will not be the same thus returning false.

oh the amount of times i have done that is unbelivable and every time i sit there fror a good half an hour going well

"a" does equal "a" so "a" == "a" is okay (change "a" to variable names or seomthing)

Jun 7th, 2005, 1:50 PM	#1
shangnyun Programmer Join Date: Jun 2005 Posts: 34 Rep Power: 0	Logical Error... :/ Help me out here, boys. I'm a newb-programmer and am really liking Java so far. I'm stuck on this problem though. Here's the code: (Toggle Plain Text) import java.util.; public class FirstProgram { public static void main(String[] args) { System.out.println("Hello out there."); System.out.println("Want to talk some more?"); System.out.println("Answer y for yes or n for no."); Scanner scannerObject = new Scanner(System.in); String answerLetter; answerLetter = scannerObject.next(); if (answerLetter == "y") System.out.println("Nice weather we are having."); if (answerLetter == "n") System.out.println("Good-bye."); System.out.println("Press Enter key to end program."); String junk; junk = scannerObject.next(); } } import java.util.; public class FirstProgram { public static void main(String[] args) { System.out.println("Hello out there."); System.out.println("Want to talk some more?"); System.out.println("Answer y for yes or n for no."); Scanner scannerObject = new Scanner(System.in); String answerLetter; answerLetter = scannerObject.next(); if (answerLetter == "y") System.out.println("Nice weather we are having."); if (answerLetter == "n") System.out.println("Good-bye."); System.out.println("Press Enter key to end program."); String junk; junk = scannerObject.next(); } } This is a problem from my book. I took the provided source-code and was supposed to change it around so that the program returns something when the user inputs the char "n". Now, this source-code comes from a book that was originally based on Java 1.4.2, so the author, Walter Savitch, provided a keyboard input class called SavitchIn.java. I have his class and could use it, but I figured I might as well try getting used to the newly introduced Scanner class in Java 5.0. Well, I'm not so sure if that was a good idea anymore. The Scanner class is driving me NUTS. The problem here is that I need to input a CHAR from the keyboard. I searched myself dumb to find if there is a char-specific input method for the Scanner class, and found nothing. There are nextInt(); nextDouble(); nextLong(); ... etc. a bunch of them like that... but no nextChar(); exists! So I figured I could try using the method for String input instead, which is just next(); So far, so good. I used this at first: (Toggle Plain Text) if (answerLetter = "y") System.out.println("Nice weather we are having."); if (answerLetter = "n") System.out.println("Good-bye."); if (answerLetter = "y") System.out.println("Nice weather we are having."); if (answerLetter = "n") System.out.println("Good-bye."); and I got no compile errors with this, but run-time errors. The compiler told me that boolean values are required here. I have no clue why... so I substituted the "="s with =='s and voila, no compile errors, no run-time errors. Great. BUT now the program has a logical error, which again I don't quite understand. It doesn't matter whether you input "y" or "n", it will always just print "Press Enter key to end program" instead of printing any of the strings in the IF statements The code is obvious/simple enoug... help a brother out!

Jun 7th, 2005, 3:00 PM	#3
Gilward Kukel Newbie Join Date: Jun 2005 Location: Vienna, Austria Posts: 15 Rep Power: 0	try this: (Toggle Plain Text) if ("y".equals(answerLetter)) System.out.println("Nice weather we are having."); if ("n".equals(answerLetter)) System.out.println("Good-bye."); if ("y".equals(answerLetter)) System.out.println("Nice weather we are having."); if ("n".equals(answerLetter)) System.out.println("Good-bye.");

Jun 7th, 2005, 8:41 PM	#7
Dameon Troll Join Date: Apr 2005 Location: Texas Posts: 732 Rep Power: 4	How about using a DataInputStream? It has a readChar method. To create one is just like with Scanner: (Toggle Plain Text) DataInputStream dataObject = new DataInputStream(System.in); DataInputStream dataObject = new DataInputStream(System.in);

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode

Jun 7th, 2005, 1:56 PM	#2
Knight Newbie Join Date: Jun 2005 Posts: 28 Rep Power: 0	Wait wait wait (brain flooded).. I've grown up on Java 1.2 and 1.4. What is the scanner class supposed to accomplish in Java 5? If I knew that, I would be of more help

Jun 7th, 2005, 3:22 PM	#4
Knight Newbie Join Date: Jun 2005 Posts: 28 Rep Power: 0	smacks himself in the head How could I forget that! I always seem to miss the little things :p . Gilward Kukel is correct. When comparing Strings, make sure to use the equals() method or the equalsIgnoreCase() method. If you're using the == to compare (2) strings, if I remember correctly, it will compare their memory addresses, which will not be the same thus returning false.

Jun 7th, 2005, 8:46 PM	#8
shangnyun Programmer Join Date: Jun 2005 Posts: 34 Rep Power: 0	I would... but I know absolutely nothing about that . My book does not at all mention that in the first chapter, and I'd like to stick to the book. However, given that I don't have the book the problem is from, that statement sorta goes out the window right there... This is the very FIRST problem in the book, from chapter 1! WTF... why can't I get this right? OMG, what will do with chapter 4 problems? Daaaayum

Jun 7th, 2005, 8:48 PM	#9
shangnyun Programmer Join Date: Jun 2005 Posts: 34 Rep Power: 0	Now that I think about it... could someone please just tell me how to use the SavitchIn class? It'll be outdated that way, but I will be done and the professor uses the old book anyway, so he's EXPECTING SavitchIn to be used. He doesn't care how we do it, so it'd be cool if I could use the Scanner class, but we're obviously having problems here . So... how do I use a random class that's not part of the standard Java package? See that link I posted earlier on info on the class. I have a SavitchIn.java file. Wha do I do with that in order to be able to use it as a class for keyboard input in my program? Thank you.

Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)

Programming Forums > Application Development > Java

Logical Error... :/